A ‘Civilised’ Nation’s Willful Ignorance about the Middle East

John Key’s embarrassing performance at seventieth UN General Assembly

I’m reblogging this from The Daily Blog:

With thanks to Malcolm Evans

With thanks to Malcolm Evans

In his address to the seventieth UN General Assembly, New Zealand Prime Minister John Key referred to his own country 15 times – or 16, if you include his expression of pride in “the values and principles that underpin the country I lead.” His opening remarks even informed delegates that, “New Zealand is a small country at the bottom of the world”. Key then went on to boldly criticise the United Nations – in particular the Security Council – referring to suffering in the Middle East that demonstrated, he said, “how far we are from achieving the aspirations of our founders and of today’s members.” He went on to assert that the UN seventieth anniversary meeting was taking place “against the backdrop of the worst refugee crisis since World War Two”, noting that this was the consequence of “the Security Council’s failure to act over the past four years.” The past four years?

Evans 4The appalling Middle East refugee tragedy actually began in 1948 with Israel’s expulsion of the Palestinian people. If John Key didn’t know that fact of history, then his speech-writers certainly let him down badly. Many ethnically-cleansed Palestinians have ended up in Syria’s Marmouk refugee camp; Lyse Doucet, chief international correspondent for the BBC, visited the refugees there last year, and described the plight of Palestinians in the camp and how armed men struggled “to contain a crowd desperate to reach a UN food distribution point” in a “desolate wasteland of utter ruin.” Ever since the catastrophe that dispossessed the native Palestinians, the Security Council’s failure to act has enabled the denial of justice to continue. In his speech, Key made ten references to Syria, speaking of it by name. However, he chose to avoid directly mentioning both Israel and Palestine, even though his speech had devoted more than a third of its length to the Middle East. The closest John Key could bring himself to mentioning Israel and Palestine was a passing reference to what he referred to as the “Middle East Peace Process.”

Read more


7 thoughts on “A ‘Civilised’ Nation’s Willful Ignorance about the Middle East

  1. Nice. Even the photo makes him look like a little boy wanting to play with the big boys.

    I wonder – does every member get their chance to point the finger at other members? What a boring job it would be to listen to the little countries…!

    Mark Wideberg

  2. I did not see your thoughts on the daily blog’s commentary or the John Key speech.
    I previously had not read key’s transcript, so moments ago I took the time to search for and to read the transcript.
    While I have reasons to criticize the speech (primarily from the doctrine of Statism, aka institutional governance), isn’t key’s assertions about Assad’s governance similar to Erdoğan’s government?
    Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, had pressed for the departure of Syrian President Bashar Assad alongside the U.S.

    Though I note more recent reports softening of that hard-line stance…

    Any news on Turkey’s NATO membership, or international monetary (G-20) consensus (away from the Washington consensus U.S. Dollar/market fundamentalism – toward multilateral/multipolar policy)?

    • Well, I deliberately didn’t comment. Just left the post speak for itself. You’re right, though. Probably I should have done the decent thing and checked out our beloved PM’s actual speech first.
      I don’t think there’s likely to be any change in Turkey’s NATO membership. Haven’t seen any news on the other business. The weekend terror attack in Ankara seems to be monoploising the news right now – as one might expect.

  3. Key is a disgusting little toadie, ex-bankster and former member of the New York Federal Reserve. He does what he’s told. People in New Plymouth reckon the National Party will roll him prior to the next election – that he’s got a job waiting for him at Goldman Sachs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s